Geneva County, Alabama
A Personal Account
GenevaAL.com
An independent blog
Not affiliated with the City of Geneva or Geneva County
Updated as events develop

Geneva County, Alabama

Evidence

Photographs, documents and footage from my own property on Faith Road, in the county — outside the Geneva city limits. Each item below links to the part of the full account it belongs to.

Video

Exhibit One

“A Six-Foot Right-of-Way”

Exhibit · The Six-Foot Claim
Loading video…

Kayleigh Austin, the Geneva Water Works manager, on the day of the installation, telling me and the responding officer that they have a six-foot right-of-way on my property. The County Engineer later confirmed the county holds no right-of-way across my land at all. I have known this since 1999.

✦
Exhibit Two

“Just Following Orders”

Exhibit · Following Orders
Loading video…

The responding Geneva officer explaining that he was acting on orders from the city manager. My property is in the county, outside the Geneva city limits. Weeks later the City of Geneva told me in writing that the Geneva Waterworks and Sewer Board works autonomously from the city, and that the city holds no records of it.

✦
Exhibit Three

Installing a Surveillance Camera on My Property

Exhibit · Faith Road
Loading video…

Chasity Royals, Kenny Royals, Jameson Herman, and an unknown female on my property installing a surveillance camera aimed at us. Jameson Herman makes an obscene gesture toward my wife, who was leaving our shop. The Royals and Hermans were walking up and down the road in a gang-like group. Mayor Hayes had declared this land a public right-of-way, and the city police — operating in the county — are backing him up, "just following orders." We are in the county, not the city. Mayor Hayes's authority here is nothing but tyranny.

✦
Exhibit Four

Moving the Meter for the Fourth Time

Exhibit · The Fourth Move · Timelapse
Loading video…

The Geneva Water Works crew moving the meter for the fourth time, recorded by my own security camera and condensed from just under an hour to about two and a half minutes. The camera's date and time stamp runs in the upper left throughout. This is the move that came within weeks of the lawsuit being filed.

✦
Exhibit Five

Narrowing the Road to Block the Campground

Exhibit · Faith Road · Driving Out
Loading video…

The view driving out from the campground property. The green flags on the left are Chasity Royals's. She and Kenny Royals narrowed the road with metal fence posts, rope, and flags set as close to the roadbed as they could manage, a wooden post at the curve, and a mailbox planted in an oversized flower pot that was moved incrementally further into the road — enough to keep a camper from being able to make the turn. Faith Road is a prescriptive easement. Neither the city, the county, nor anyone living on it holds title to it. Chasity put the fence up at the edge of the graded road. The road grader would move over a bit to avoid the fence, the grass would grow, then she would move the fence to the edge of the grass again. It is a slow process but it is effective. After I put the trailer on the property Chasity removed her fence. I guess she was thinking RVs would have been better than trailers.

✦

Photographs & Documents

Exhibit Six

The City Disclaims the Water Board

Letter from the City of Geneva dated September 16, 2024
The City of Geneva's reply to my public records request. The city's position is that the Geneva Waterworks and Sewer Board “works autonomously from the City,” that the council's only role is appointing its board members, and that the city holds no records of the board at all.Click the photograph to enlarge.
Exhibit Seven

The Right-of-Way Line and the Meter

Blue line marking the end of the county right-of-way with the meter beyond it
The blue line is where the county measured and marked the end of the right-of-way for the Water Department. The meter sits past it, on my land, with the steel T-posts standing around it.Click the photograph to enlarge.
Exhibit Eight

The Posts Around the Meter

Three steel T-posts driven into the ground around the water meter
Three steel T-posts driven in around the meter, in the area where vehicles park and turn. These are fence posts, driven deep enough to stand on their own.Click the photograph to enlarge.
Exhibit Nine

The Camera and the Officer

A Geneva police officer beside the trail camera mounted on a steel post
The responding Geneva officer at the scene, with the camera the neighbors had strapped to one of the steel posts on my property and aimed at us. He called the placement unreasonable and made them take it down.Click the photograph to enlarge.
Exhibit Ten

After the Fourth Move

Water meter lids set unevenly in bare churned dirt
The meter after the fourth and final move, off my land and onto the state right-of-way, photographed a day or two after the crew left. The lids sit at different heights and face different directions in bare dirt, with nothing put back the way they found it.Click the photograph to enlarge.
Exhibit Eleven

The Posts in the Curve

Steel posts and wire set along the inside of the curve on Faith Road
Steel posts and wire set along the curve in front of Chasity Royals's yard. The telephone pole is approximately the property line. Cars stay to the inside of the curve, which is why grass grows on that ground at all — but a trailer or a camper has to swing wide across exactly that strip to make the turn. The posts made that impossible.Click the photograph to enlarge.
✦
Exhibit Twelve

The Board’s Attorney Answers

Letter from attorney Alfred J. Danner dated October 7, 2024
The reply from the Geneva Water Works and Sewer Board’s attorney. One paragraph, asserting a sixty-foot right-of-way on Highway 52 and a twenty-foot right-of-way on Faith Road, and declining to address anything else in my letter.Click the photograph to enlarge.
✦
Exhibit Thirteen

The Meter Moved Back

The water meter moved back with three steel T-posts around it
After the Water Department moved the meter back onto my property, with the three steel T-posts driven in around it.Click the photograph to enlarge.
✦
Exhibit Fourteen

The Mailbox, Before the Flower Pot

Chasity Royals's mailbox set in the ground beside Faith Road
Chasity Royals’s mailbox where it stood in the ground, before she replanted it in an oversized flower pot and began moving it out into the road.Click the photograph to enlarge.
✦
Exhibit Fifteen

The County’s Answer

Geneva County Commission response dated October 15, 2024
Geneva County Commission, October 15, 2024. The checked box reads: “Faith Road is a prescriptive public right-of-way and not a deeded public right-of-way.”Click the letter to enlarge.
✦
Exhibit Sixteen

No Right-of-Way Deeds, 2004

Letter from Geneva County Engineer Roy F. Powell dated January 12, 2004
Roy F. Powell, then Geneva County Engineer, January 12, 2004: “I have researched the property records and can find no right of way deeds for Faith Lane.” Written twenty years before this dispute began.Click the letter to enlarge.
✦
Exhibit Seventeen

The 2019 Survey

2019 boundary survey by PLS Group, Inc. of Troy, Alabama showing Alabama State Highway 52 with a 100-foot right-of-way
Boundary survey by PLS Group, Inc. of Troy, September 19, 2019. The only right-of-way on the drawing is ALABAMA STATE HIGHWAY 52 (100' R/W) — the State’s, not the Water Department’s. Full survey (PDF)Click the survey to enlarge.
✦
Exhibit Eighteen

The Cease and Desist

Cease and desist letter dated October 5, 2024 addressed to the Geneva Waterworks and Sewer Board members by name
October 5, 2024, addressed to the board members by name — including David Hayes, Mayor of Geneva, as a Member. Marked “No reply” in my own hand. Full letter (PDF)Click the letter to enlarge.
✦
Exhibit Nineteen

Paragraph 25

Paragraph 25 of the complaint, referring to negligent construction of a home at 916 County Road 610, Enterprise, Alabama, with a handwritten note in the margin reading: not this case, another client's file
From my own complaint, filed December 6, 2024. There is no home and no construction in this case, and that address is in another county. The red marks are mine, added here — the filed document has nothing written on it. Full complaint (PDF)Click to enlarge.
✦
Exhibit Twenty

The Board’s Answer

Defenses six through nine of the Board's answer, pleading Alabama Code sections 11-47-190, 11-93-2 and 6-11-26
Defenses 6, 7 and 9 — the statutes written for cities and their boards.
Defenses thirteen through sixteen of the Board's answer, pleading four forms of immunity
Defenses 13 through 16 — four separate pleas of immunity.

Filed March 7, 2025 by Shealy, Pike & Hornsby of Dothan. Eight pages, twenty defenses, and no deed, plat or recorded easement anywhere in it. Full answer (PDF)

✦
Exhibit Twenty-One

What the Board Said About Me

Defenses four and five of the Board's answer: the plaintiff's own actions contributed to the harm he claims, and the plaintiff assumed the risk and consequences of his actions
Defenses 4 and 5, page 5 of the answer.
Defense twenty of the Board's answer: the Board pleads unclean hands
Defense 20, the last one on the list, page 6.

Three of the twenty defenses argue about my conduct rather than about the law. Unclean hands is a doctrine of equity: a court must refuse relief to a party who has acted in bad faith regarding the subject of the claim — he who comes into equity must come with clean hands. Nine lines above it, Defense 11 pleads lack of causation, that the Board did not cause the harm. Nowhere in the eight pages does the Board state a single thing I am alleged to have done. Full answer (PDF)

✦
Exhibit Twenty-Two

The Name Comes Off

Signature page of the 2026 Certificate of Amendment
Signed April 15, 2026 by David B. Hayes, Chairman and Kayleigh Austin, Manager.
Alabama Secretary of State name reservation certificate
Reserved for the exclusive use of David B. Hayes, April 21, 2026.

On April 21, 2026 The Water Works and Sewer Board of the City of Geneva became Greater Geneva Water Authority. The Secretary of State's record lists one amendment: “Only Name Change.” Full filing (PDF)

Disclaimer

This is an independent, privately operated website. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or associated with the City of Geneva, Geneva County government, the Geneva Water Works and Sewer Board, or any other governmental entity in any manner whatsoever. The accountability reporting on this page reflects the documented personal experience and opinion of a private property owner in Geneva County, Alabama. All factual claims are based on firsthand experience, documented records, on-the-record conversations, and — where noted in the text — information relayed to me by people I trust, which I could not independently confirm. Readers are encouraged to conduct their own research and draw their own conclusions. Nothing on this site constitutes legal advice.