Geneva County, Alabama
A Personal Account
GenevaAL.com
An independent blog
Not affiliated with the City of Geneva or Geneva County
Updated as events develop

When the Government Comes for Your Property

A documented account of unauthorized utility installation, political favoritism, and the abuse of public authority in Geneva County, Alabama.

What This Comes Down To The Geneva Water Works put a water meter on my property to serve a neighbor's house nearly four hundred feet away. Nobody asked me.

When I asked what gave them the right to be there, I got four different answers. The water department manager gave me one. The Board's attorney gave me another in writing. The City of Geneva's answer was that the water board wasn't theirs. And Geneva County — the only one of them that ever produced a document — backed up my position. Nobody has shown me a deed, a plat, or a recorded easement.

A police officer brokered an agreement and the meter was moved off my property. Days later the Water Department put it back on my land, and I was told my property had been declared public. That is when the tyranny doubled down. It took hiring an attorney and filing a lawsuit to get the meter off my land and onto the state right-of-way.

That is what this is about. Everything below is the record, with the documents.
Blue line marking the end of the county right-of-way, with the water meter sitting beyond it on private property

The blue line is where the county measured and marked the end of the right-of-way. The meter sits past it, on my land. This was the third install.

The Unauthorized Meter Installation

It began when I arrived at my property to find workers from the Geneva Water Works in the process of installing a water meter — one I had never requested.

My neighbor, Kenny Royals, husband of Chasity Royals, was present and watching. I immediately told the crew they could not install the meter on my property and asked that they should move it to Chasity's front yard or at a minimum to a location that would not encroach on my land. I have never seen a water meter installed several hundred feet away from the home it was serving. Chasity's home is nearly 400 feet away.

The Geneva Police arrived shortly after. I explained the situation, and the officers spoke with the Water Department crew. To my surprise, the officers on scene seemed to understand and sympathize with my problem. However, when the Water Department manager, Kayleigh Austin, arrived, she insisted the Water Department held a six-foot right-of-way around the perimeter of my property. It didn't — the County Engineer later confirmed as much. Austin also told me the line they'd tapped into was a water main. It wasn't: I'd paid the Water Department years earlier to run a one-inch branch line under Highway 52 to serve my property alone, sized for one customer, not a main. Two flatly wrong statements, delivered with total confidence, from the person running the department.

Exhibit · The Six-Foot Claim
Loading video…

Kayleigh Austin, the Water Works manager, on the day of the installation, telling me and the responding officer that the Water Department has a six-foot right-of-way on my property. The County Engineer later confirmed the county holds no right-of-way across my land at all.

Exhibit · Following Orders
Loading video…

The responding Geneva officer explaining that he was acting on orders from the city manager. My property is in the county, outside the city limits. Weeks later the city told me in writing that the Water Board works autonomously and that it holds no records of it.

Who Kayleigh Austin Is

Austin's promotion from clerk to Water Department manager was, by many accounts, the product of an extra special friendship with Mayor David B. Hayes — not professional merit. Mayor Hayes is not only the Mayor of Geneva; he is also a member of the very Water Board that employs Austin. It later came to light that Austin and Chasity Royals — the neighbor at the center of this dispute — were long-time friends.

Some would ask why I would fight this. It is simple. First, the land is mine and no one asked permission to use it. Second, had they asked, I would have said no — because several years earlier I had asked Chasity and her late husband if I could buy water from them for my rental property until I could get the well repaired or municipal water installed. Phillip, her husband at the time — salt of the earth — was agreeable, but after talking with his wife, called me back and told me she'd refused because she didn't like my tenant. As Phillip explained it, the disagreement traced back to an incident involving Chasity's pit bull: my tenant claimed the dog had growled at her and her children. My tenant confronted Chasity about the dog and there were “harsh” words. My other commercial tenants — a husband and wife — said they'd had the same problem with the dog.

I want to be clear about one thing, because it matters for everything that comes later. That disagreement was between Chasity and my tenant. It was not between Chasity and me. I let it go years ago. Phillip was a friend, and we kept a neighborly relationship with that family long afterward. Nothing between us changed until the meter.

I was fortunate that a neighboring church came to my aid and allowed me to buy water from them. Had that not happened, my tenants would have had to move. I didn't get next-day service from the Water Department either — it took them over two months to install my meter.

What appeared on the surface to be a routine utility matter was, in reality, a web of personal relationships being exercised against a private citizen who had done nothing more than say no.

"I demanded documentation of any easement or right-of-way. They produced nothing — not that day, not ever. The assertion of authority was the only authority they had."

The officer made several phone calls, and eventually an older gentleman arrived in a white truck. The officer spoke with him privately, then came to me and said that an agreement had been reached: the meter would be placed on the other side of my fence post, off my property. I accepted those terms. The meter was moved, and the matter appeared settled.

It is worth noting that this fence post had been placed following a professional survey done years earlier by PLS out of Troy — excellent surveyors. When I later spoke with the County Engineer, he confirmed that the county held no right-of-way along Faith Road, and that the state's right-of-way for Highway 52 extended 100 feet total — 50 feet either side of the centerline. That measurement aligned perfectly with my post. He refused to provide me a copy of the survey, however, claiming the file was too large because it covered the entire Highway 52 corridor in Geneva County. He also told me that he had relayed this same information to Mayor Hayes very early in the dispute. This conversation took place before the lawsuit was filed.

Exhibit · The 2019 Survey 2019 boundary survey by PLS Group, Inc. of Troy, Alabama, showing Alabama State Highway 52 with a 100-foot right-of-way and no easement across the parcels
The boundary survey by PLS Group, Inc. of Troy, September 19, 2019. The property was originally one parcel addressed 164 Faith Road. I built the retail space near the highway, which became 1932 AL-52, and the warehouse behind it, which became 138 Faith Road. This survey divided the property, and I sold the house at 164. The only right-of-way a licensed surveyor put on this drawing is along the highway: ALABAMA STATE HIGHWAY 52 (100' R/W) — the same hundred feet the County Engineer described to me. It is the State's. It is not the Water Department's, and there is no six-foot strip anywhere on it. Full survey (PDF)Click the survey to enlarge.

The Agreement Is Broken

A few days later, my commercial tenant informed me that the Water Department had returned and moved the meter back onto my property. I contacted the officer who had brokered the agreement. He came out, surveyed the situation, and said plainly, "I thought we had an agreement."

In addition to moving the meter, the Royals had come onto my property and driven three steel rods into the ground around the meter for a second time — in my parking area. Chasity Royals later admitted they had installed the rods, and I have this on video. Kayleigh Austin claimed the Water Department had placed the rods, relayed to me through the police officer. I have that exchange on video as well. Someone was lying, and I am guessing it was Austin. The rods posed a genuine safety hazard; someone could easily fall and be seriously injured or damage their vehicle.

Install 1 - three steel T-posts driven in around the water meter
Three steel T-posts driven in around the meter, in the area where vehicles park and turn.
Install 2 - the meter moved off the property beside the mailbox
Where the meter sat after the officer brokered the agreement — off my property, past the fence post.
Install 3 - the meter back on the property, past the blue line marking the end of the right-of-way
The blue line is where the county measured and marked the end of the right-of-way. The meter sits past it, on my land. The steel T-posts obstructed the flow of traffic off of Faith Road into and out of my parking lot.
Install 4 - the meter in its final position in bare dirt, no posts
The fourth and final position, closer to the highway, no posts — off my land and onto the state right-of-way. This one came within weeks of the lawsuit being filed. The lids sit at different heights and face different directions, in bare churned dirt.

The same meter, four positions, in order. Click any frame to enlarge.

The officer called Kayleigh Austin, who now claimed the Water Department had installed the rods and that the city had determined it did have a right-of-way on my property. The officer also reached the City Manager's office, which reportedly suggested that if I disturbed the area — which I had stated I intended to do, given the safety hazard — I should be arrested. On my own property.

According to Chasity Royals, a meeting had taken place just days before involving Mayor David B. Hayes, the Water Department, and others — she did not give full details — a meeting she herself was invited to attend, at which she says the Mayor declared my property a public right-of-way. I was not present at that meeting, and this account rests entirely on what Chasity Royals told me; I was not able to independently confirm it. I'll note, though, that the Water Department moving the meter back onto my property days later — with nothing having changed on my end — is at least consistent with her account; something prompted that decision, and no one has ever offered another explanation for it. If accurate, let that settle: a sitting mayor convened a meeting about a private citizen's land, held that meeting on that citizen's property without the citizen present, and decreed it public property. My property is not within the city limits. That is not governance. That is the tyrannical exercise of power by a man who apparently believed his title gave him the right to simply take what was convenient.

It is also worth understanding why the Royals wanted municipal water in the first place. Their well had failed, and it was cheaper to connect to city water than to repair it. That is the origin of this entire dispute — and it explains why Austin, whose relationship with Hayes had placed her in her position, and whose friendship with Chasity Royals gave her a personal stake in the outcome, was willing to go as far as she did.

The County Engineer's office later explained that neither the county nor the city actually owns Faith Road — it's only a prescriptive easement, one the county has long maintained without ever holding title to it — and that this was why the Water Department had no legal right to install infrastructure down it. My own view: if they had ignored that and simply run a proper water main down the road, no one would likely have objected, and I would have benefited along with everyone else — we'd all have come out ahead. Instead, I was the easier, cheaper target. A path for the water line could have been condemned down the center of the road for the Water Department's use, but that cost money and time. I had already paid to cross Highway 52 on my own dime, and the Water Department tapped into that line for the Royals. The Royals then ran their own line down Faith Road. The Water Department could have easily done this properly. The precedent that sets is worth naming plainly: if you live down a dirt road and the Water Department won't run a proper line down it, expect them to install a meter in front of the nearest property instead and leave you to run your own line from there to wherever you actually need the water.

Three Different Right-of-Ways

By the autumn of 2024 I had been given three different answers about the same ground, and not one of the people giving them produced a document.

I submitted Alabama's equivalent of Freedom of Information Act requests to the City of Geneva, the Geneva Water Works Board, and the County Engineer's office. The city denied any association with the Water Department — I have their letter.

Exhibit · The City's Response Letter from the City of Geneva dated September 16, 2024 denying any records of the Water Board
The City of Geneva's reply to my public records request. The city's position is that the Geneva Waterworks and Sewer Board “works autonomously from the City,” that the council's only role is appointing its board members, and that the city holds no records of the board at all.Click the photograph to enlarge.

On September 6, 2024 I wrote to the Geneva Water Works and Sewer Board setting out my objections and asking them to address a list of items. On October 7 their attorney, Alfred J. Danner, answered.

Exhibit · The Board's Answer Letter from attorney Alfred J. Danner dated October 7, 2024 on behalf of the Geneva Water Works and Sewer Board
The reply from the Board's attorney, copied to the Geneva Water Works and Sewer Board. One paragraph, asserting a right-of-way and declining to address anything else.Click the letter to enlarge.

His answer ran one paragraph. The new meter, he wrote, “was next to two existing meters which lie within the 60 foot Right of Way of Highway 52 and the 20 foot Right of Way of Faith Road,” and because the meter lies within the right-of-way, “there is no need to address the other items listed in your letter.” That sentence did two jobs. It asserted a right-of-way, and it used the assertion to decline every other question I had asked.

The two existing meters he refers to are mine. One serves my retail space, one serves my warehouse — two buildings that touch but are separate. Those meters are there because I paid the Water Department to run a one-inch line under Highway 52 to serve my property, sized for one customer. That there are meters on my own land serving my own buildings is not evidence that the land is a public right-of-way. It is evidence that the land is mine. The Water Department's argument is that because the Water Department installed meters on my land, for my use, I no longer owned the land.

Then there are the numbers. On August 23 the Water Department manager, Kayleigh Austin, told me and the responding officer that the Water Department held a six-foot right-of-way across my property — six feet, as my complaint later recorded it, “along all sides of” my property. That is on video, further up this page. The county's position was already the opposite, and had been for twenty years — no right-of-way deed, as its own engineer wrote in 2004 and as the Commission confirmed again in October 2024. The County Engineer also told me he had relayed that same information to Mayor Hayes early on, and Hayes sits on the Water Board. On October 7 the Board's own attorney put different figures in writing — sixty feet on Highway 52, twenty feet on Faith Road.

The County Engineer told me something different again. The state's right-of-way on Highway 52 is one hundred feet in total, fifty feet either side of the centerline. The county holds no right-of-way across my land. And the county does not own Faith Road at all. It has a prescriptive easement — the right to go on maintaining a road it has maintained for years — and nothing more. There is no twenty-foot Faith Road right-of-way for a meter to sit in, because there is no Faith Road right-of-way. And the additional six feet on both sides that Austin referred to does not exist either. Twenty feet of road with six feet added on each side would be thirty-two feet in all — thirty-two feet of ground the county says it holds no deed to.

One more thing about the sixty feet. The County Engineer's office told me the state's right-of-way on Highway 52 is one hundred feet in total, fifty either side of the centerline. Danner wrote sixty. Read as sixty feet in total it is smaller than the state's; read as sixty feet from the centerline it is larger. Neither reading is the figure the county gave me. And if sixty feet means the whole right-of-way, it is narrower than the hundred feet the county describes — a narrower right-of-way reaches onto my property less, not more. That reading does not help the Board. The only reading that does is sixty feet from the centerline, which is a hundred and twenty feet in total, twenty feet wider than the state's. The letter does not say that. It says sixty.

Set against the dates, none of it settles. On August 23 it was six feet. On September 6 I wrote the Board. On September 14 I asked Geneva County for every record it held on right-of-ways, easements and surveys for these parcels and for Faith Road. On September 16 the city told me the Board was not theirs. On October 5 I sent the Board a cease and desist and got no reply. On October 7 the Board's attorney told me sixty feet on Highway 52, twenty feet on Faith Road, and that nothing further needed answering. On October 15 the county answered — and the county was the only one of them that produced a document. That answer, and the letter it attached, are in the next section.

The timing is worth noting too. I wrote the Board on September 6. On September 16 the City of Geneva told me the Water Board runs autonomously and that the city holds no records of it. On October 7 the Board's attorney told me the meter was in a right-of-way and that nothing else needed answering. Both doors shut inside a month.

In between those two dates I sent the Board a cease and desist. I addressed it to the members by name.

Exhibit · The Cease and Desist Cease and desist letter dated October 5, 2024 addressed to the Geneva Waterworks and Sewer Board members by name, marked No reply
My cease and desist to the Geneva Waterworks & Sewer Board, October 5, 2024. The handwriting at the top is mine, written on my own copy at the time: “No reply.” It is still accurate. Full letter (PDF)Click the letter to enlarge.

Read the addressee block. Randall Meeks — Member. Rufus Lee — Member. Kim Gillespie — Member. David Hayes — Member. Charlie Fleming — Chairman.

That is the Mayor of Geneva, sitting as a member of the board that the City of Geneva had told me three weeks earlier it had no association with and held no records of. I did not learn that later or piece it together afterward. I typed those names onto a letter in October 2024, and nobody wrote back to tell me I had it wrong.

The Water Works Board responded with a letter from Al Danner — the same attorney who had handled the title work on my property years earlier; his name is on my deed. Someone close to me who has spoken with Mayor Hayes directly — Hayes sits on the Water Board himself — told me Hayes said this was a conflict of interest the Board was aware of. I can't independently confirm that beyond what was relayed to me, but Hayes would have no obvious reason to invent a conflict involving his own board. I will put it no higher than this: the records a man searches to do title work on a property are the same records the County Engineer searched in 2004, and he found no right-of-way deed in them.

I do not understand how Alfred Danner wrote that letter. He has spent many years doing title work in this county. He did the title work on this very property — his name is on the deed we were fighting over. Searching a title means going through the same records the County Engineer went through in 2004, and the engineer found no right-of-way deed in them. I am not going to tell you what was in Danner's head. What I will say is that of everyone who told me there was a right-of-way across my land, he is the one who had already been through the records.

Twenty Years Earlier: The Corner

The county's answer pointed to an attachment — a letter written twenty years before any of this began. I am putting both here in full, because together they do two things at once.

Exhibit · The County's Answer Geneva County Commission response dated October 15, 2024 stating Faith Road is a prescriptive public right-of-way and not a deeded public right-of-way
Geneva County Commission, October 15, 2024. The checked box reads: “Faith Road is a prescriptive public right-of-way and not a deeded public right-of-way.”
Exhibit · The 2004 Letter Letter from Geneva County Engineer Roy F. Powell dated January 12, 2004 regarding encroachments on Faith Lane
Roy F. Powell, then Geneva County Engineer, January 12, 2004. He searched the records and found no right-of-way deed for the road.

The first thing they do is settle the question Danner's letter tried to answer. Powell wrote: “I have researched the property records and can find no right of way deeds for Faith Lane. It appears that lots were sold by metes and bounds descriptions without setting aside a fixed right of way.” A county engineer went through the records twenty years before any of this started, with nothing at stake either way, and found no right-of-way deed. The county said the same thing again in October 2024. There is no twenty-foot Faith Road right-of-way for a meter to sit in.

The second thing that 2004 letter does is complain about me.

Twenty years ago I was the one with fence and posts along that road, and I am not going to leave that out. Here is what it was about. Roughly seven years before — before we owned the land — neighbors moving a mobile home in cleared the trees out of our corner to get it through. Traffic began cutting across the bare ground instead of going around, and people started taking that corner fast on what had always been a quiet dead-end road. Cars lost control there and ended up in Eugene Herman's yard. Herman lived in the house Chasity Royals lives in today. He is her father-in-law, now deceased. He is the one who asked us to take our corner back.

Before we closed it I spoke with James Kelly, a Geneva lawyer who called himself a county lawyer rather than an attorney, and a fighter. We put the posts up and the complaint followed, and the loudest part of it was that a fire truck could not make the corner. So we set a time and they brought a fire truck out. It made the corner with no issue.

They still wanted something out of it, so we let them set the new post themselves, wherever they wanted it. They put in an old wooden bridge beam — a formidable piece of lumber — a couple of feet past our property line, which cut the tip off our corner. We never gave up our rights to that tip. We gave everyone permission to cross it. On the stretch before the curve they calculated seventeen feet of road. We measured and set our posts at exactly seventeen feet.

And the cleared corner itself had only existed about seven years. By Powell's own account in that same letter, a prescriptive easement matures after twenty years of public use without hindrance from the owner. Seven is not twenty.

So yes — twenty years ago the county wrote to me about fence and posts on Faith Road, and I moved them to where the county asked. That is the difference. I was restoring a boundary at a neighbor's request, I tested their claim and it failed, and I gave ground to settle it.

A Note on What Makes a Road Public Alabama treats a road as public by prescription after twenty years of continuous public use without let or hindrance from the owner — the same standard Roy Powell set out in his 2004 letter. Two things follow from that. Use the owner permits is not adverse use: a landowner who lets people cross while making clear it is permission and not a surrender of ownership keeps the ground. And the character of the use matters, including whether the general public uses a road or only the people who live on it. Faith Road is a dead end. Where a county wants more than prescription gives it, the law provides a route — Ala. Code § 23-1-82 grants counties the power of eminent domain for establishing and changing roads.

Seeking Legal Counsel in a County That Protects Its Own

I consulted two attorneys in Geneva. The first told me it would be very difficult to find local representation because virtually every attorney in town was competing for contracts with the city. The second declined outright, explaining that he would have to continue working with these same individuals long after my matter was resolved. He also warned me candidly: expect that any procedural misstep on my part would be seized upon and exploited. He described Mayor Hayes, former Judge Fleming, the rest of the Water Board, and the City Council as a formidable and tightly aligned group — all of them friends. I had great respect for Judge Fleming up to that point. He was the only person I had ever crossed party lines to vote for. He ran for judge as a Democrat.

After exhausting my local options, I contacted an attorney in Enterprise. He also declined, citing Geneva County's well-known reputation for disregarding the law — noting that Geneva County came up in Bar Association meetings in Montgomery more often than any other county in the state. He did, however, offer useful background on the Water Department after reviewing a letter I had received from the city disavowing any relationship with it. He explained that the Water Department was a nonprofit corporation — quasi-public in nature, meaning it performs government-like services but is not actually a government entity. It is not a part of the city in any formal sense, except that the city council appoints the board members, as required by its own charter. No charter has ever been presented to me for inspection. This classification affords it significant financial opacity: nonprofits in Alabama are not required to open their books the way city or county governments are, and if they do produce financial statements, those statements are not held to normal business standards. He mentioned that a water department in the City of Prichard had been investigated by the state for operating essentially as a personal slush fund for its board members. You can search "Guccigate Alabama" for more on that story. To be clear, I'm not suggesting Geneva Water Works has done the same thing — only that this kind of financial opacity is what nonprofit-structured utilities like it are legally permitted under Alabama law, whatever has or hasn't happened here.

The County Engineer's office said I had submitted my request incorrectly and denied it, but they were ultimately the most helpful — they spoke with me by phone in detail, confirmed they had no claim to my property, that they did not own Faith Road, and that the state held no right-of-way across my land. They explained that they had maintained Faith Road for many years and had the right to continue doing so, but nothing beyond that. The county could condemn my land if it chose to, but there is a process: the County Engineer told me the county's standard calls for 63 feet of total road width, and under Alabama law the county would have to pay just compensation — the value of the land taken plus any resulting damage to what's left, including devaluation. That could cost the county a hundred thousand, or even hundreds of thousands, depending on what the appraisals showed.

Filing Suit

The Enterprise attorney referred me to a newer attorney who was working to build his reputation and had already sued Coffee County. I hired him, despite some misgivings.

In almost exactly one month from filing the lawsuit, the Geneva Water Works came out and moved the meter for the fourth time — this time off my property and onto the state right-of-way, just barely, and they did an ugly job of it — that is Install 4 in the sequence above. I imagine they were tired of moving the meter, and perhaps Austin or Hayes told them to make it look as bad as possible. When I informed my attorney, his reaction was that it was an admission of their wrong doing.

Exhibit · The Fourth Move · Timelapse
Loading video…

The Geneva Water Works crew moving the meter for the fourth time, recorded by my own security camera and condensed from just under an hour to about two and a half minutes. The camera's date and time stamp runs in the upper left throughout. This is the move that came within weeks of the lawsuit being filed.

The complaint was filed in the Circuit Court of Geneva County on December 6, 2024, as case CV-2024-900131. It runs eleven pages across five counts — slander of title, trespass, negligence, negligent hiring and supervision, and fraud. The full complaint is here (PDF), with my name and address removed and the property address left in.

One paragraph of it has nothing to do with this case — leftover text from another client's file that my attorney never took out. I have set it out at the foot of this page.

What the Board Filed in Court

The Board was served. It hired a law firm. On March 7, 2025 it filed an eight-page answer. I am putting the whole thing here, because what is in it matters less than what is not.

The answer came through Steadman S. Shealy, Jr., of Shealy, Pike & Hornsby in Dothan. It runs through my complaint line by line, then sets out twenty defenses. The full answer is here (PDF).

Three of those defenses should be read next to the letter the City of Geneva sent me in September.

Exhibit · Defenses 6, 7 and 9 Defenses six through nine of the Board's answer, pleading Alabama Code sections 11-47-190, 11-93-2 and 6-11-26
From page 5 of the Board's answer, March 7, 2025.Click to enlarge.

Title 11 of the Alabama Code is titled Counties and Municipal Corporations. Section 11-47-190 opens with the words “No city or town shall be liable for damages” — it is the statute that limits what a municipality can be sued for. Section 11-93-2 caps damages against a “governmental entity,” a term the statute defines to include any department, agency, board or commission of a municipality.

In my complaint I had pleaded that the Board is an Alabama domestic non-profit corporation — Secretary of State entity number 000-810-824, with no registered agent listed — and argued that it was a corporate entity rather than a governmental one. The answer took the opposite position, and asked the court for the protections the law gives a city and a city's board.

The City of Geneva told me in writing that the Water Board runs autonomously and that the city holds no records of it. The Board told the court it was entitled to the statutes written for cities. Both of those documents are on this page. They cannot both be describing the same thing.

Four more defenses asked for immunity outright.

Exhibit · Defenses 13 through 16 Defenses thirteen through sixteen of the Board's answer, pleading immunity, State-agent immunity, discretionary function immunity and substantive immunity
From page 6 of the Board's answer, March 7, 2025.Click to enlarge.

I am not a lawyer and I am not going to tell you what a court would have made of any of that. Read it and decide for yourself.

Then there is what the Board said about me.

Three of the twenty defenses do not argue about the law at all. They argue about my conduct.

Exhibit · What the Board Said About Me Defenses four and five of the Board's answer: the plaintiff's own actions contributed to the harm he claims, and the plaintiff assumed the risk and consequences of his actions

Defenses 4 and 5, from page 5 of the Board's answer.

Defense twenty of the Board's answer: the Board pleads unclean hands

Defense 20, the last one on the list, from page 6.

Read the full eight-page answer (PDF)Click either line to enlarge.

I read those three together as the Board telling a court that I brought this on myself.

I did not install the meter. I did not drive the posts. I did not move it, and I did not move it back. I asked what gave them the right to be on my property, and when I did not get a straight answer I asked in writing. That is the whole list of things I did.

Nowhere in the eight pages does the Board say what those actions of mine were supposed to be. Not one fact. The first five pages are a paragraph-by-paragraph list of admissions and denials; the defenses run from page five to page six; page seven is the certificate of service. Nothing in any of it describes a single thing I am alleged to have done.

And nine lines above the unclean hands defense, at number 11, the same filing pleads lack of causation — that the Board did not cause the harm. Those are two different stories. Either somebody caused this or nobody did.

I know defenses get pleaded in bulk. I know a lawyer works down a list and checks boxes, and that the same twenty include release, waiver, laches and estoppel. That does not change what was filed with the court, under a signature, on March 7, 2025. It says I came to court dirty. Nobody has ever told me how.

Here is what I keep coming back to. The Board was served. It hired a firm in Dothan. It filed eight pages. My attorney ran a title search before he filed, and found nothing. And nowhere in those eight pages is there a deed, a plat, a recorded easement, or a book-and-page number for the right-of-way its manager told a police officer ran along all sides of my property. If one existed, that was the document to put it in.

The Name Comes Off

Thirteen months after the Board asked a court for the protections the law gives a city and a city's board, it stopped calling itself one.

On April 8, 2026 the board adopted a name change. On April 21 it was filed with the Alabama Secretary of State. The Water Works and Sewer Board of the City of Geneva became Greater Geneva Water Authority.

The filing is a Domestic Nonprofit Corporation Certificate of Amendment, made under the Alabama Nonprofit Corporation Law — Title 10A, Chapter 3A — on entity number 000-810-824, formed April 7, 1947. Under the Secretary of State's heading for optional amendments, the record says one thing: “Only Name Change.” Nothing about who appoints the board. Nothing about the service area. Nothing about how it is governed. Just the name.

Two people signed it. David B. Hayes, Chairman. Kayleigh Austin, Manager.

The same manager who told me and a Geneva police officer that the Water Department held a six-foot right-of-way along all sides of my property. And the Mayor of Geneva — who in October 2024, when I addressed my cease and desist to the board by name, was listed as a Member, with Charlie Fleming as Chairman.

Two pages of that filing are worth seeing together — the certificate the Secretary of State issued, and the signatures on the amendment it was filed with.

Exhibit · The 2026 Amendment Alabama Secretary of State name reservation certificate for Greater Geneva Water Authority

The Secretary of State's name reservation certificate, April 21, 2026.

Signature page of the 2026 Certificate of Amendment, signed by the chairman and the manager

Page 2 of the Certificate of Amendment it was filed with, signed April 15, 2026.

Read the full seven-page filing (PDF)Click either page to enlarge.
“This name reservation is for the exclusive use of David B. Hayes, P.O. Box 370, Geneva, AL 36340 for a period of one year beginning 04/21/2026 and expiring 04/21/2027.”

There may be an ordinary explanation. Utilities that serve customers well outside the city limits — I am one of them, my property is in the county — rename themselves to reflect it, and somebody has to put a name on a reservation form. I am not claiming otherwise. I am saying the dates are the dates.

For seventy-nine years this entity carried the City of Geneva in its name — as the Water Works Board of the City of Geneva from 1947, and as the Water Works and Sewer Board of the City of Geneva from 1970. In April 2026 it stopped.

In September 2024 the City of Geneva told me the Water Board runs autonomously and that the city holds no records of it. In March 2025 the Board asked a court for the protections the law gives a city and a city's board. In April 2026 the Mayor of Geneva, sitting as chairman of that board, reserved the name that took the City of Geneva out of its title.

The Settlement — and Unanswered Questions

The Water Department retained a high-profile attorney from Dothan, Steadman Shealy. My attorney's demeanor shifted noticeably — he seemed either impressed or intimidated. He immediately pushed to settle. When I refused, he said, "Which hill do you want to die on?" I knew at that point his resolve had evaporated. He argued that since the meter had been moved, the judge would likely dismiss the case and I would spend significant money for nothing. We had agreed we would complete discovery before entertaining any settlement discussions, so we could at least have a record of the Water Department's conduct. In their filed response to the lawsuit (Case No. CV-2024-900131.00 · Geneva County Circuit Court), the Water Department also claimed to be a state agency — a notable shift from the "not actually a government entity" description I'd been given earlier in this same process. He agreed to hold off on settlement talks — and then ignored that agreement entirely.

Without conducting discovery, he opened settlement negotiations. He reported that the Water Department had offered a settlement amount. I refused and reminded him of what we had agreed to. He became argumentative. A few days later he called back with a slightly higher offer, still with no discovery completed. My wife, knowing the toll this ordeal had taken on us, wanted it to be over. I reluctantly agreed.

What Was Paid

Settlement I Received $4,000
Amount Hayes Reportedly Told Someone Close to Me Was Actually Paid $7,000 Relayed to me secondhand — I could not independently confirm this figure.
Apology the Water Department's Own Attorney Reportedly Said I Was Owed Never Received

I had paid my attorney's retainer long before the settlement, so the $3,000 difference cannot be explained as attorney's fees; had that been the arrangement, it should have been disclosed and the remainder paid to me. I have no reason to doubt the person who relayed the $7,000 figure to me, but no one has offered any accounting of the difference, if it ever existed.

What the Declaration Set Loose

Everything in this section and the ones after it follows from one thing: a mayor telling people my land was public.

Mayor Hayes had declared my property a public right-of-way — without ever notifying me, without any legal basis, and without my presence at the meeting where that declaration was reportedly made. What followed was a direct consequence of that claim: my neighbors felt empowered to do as they pleased on land that was not theirs.

The video below was recorded on my property on Faith Road — in the county, not the city. In it, you can see Chasity Royals, Kenny Royals, Jameson Herman, and an unknown female from the neighboring family on my land installing a surveillance camera aimed at us. The neighbors were walking up and down the road in a gang-like group. As they are filmed, Jameson Herman makes an obscene gesture toward my wife, who was leaving our shop. My wife states that Kenny Royals made the same gesture as she was turning left onto Highway 52, after the phone had been put down to make the turn. That moment is not on the video.

This is the same incident the responding officer later called unreasonable. He forced them to remove the camera — even while city officials were backing Mayor Hayes's claim that the land wasn't mine. The city police have jurisdiction to enforce state law out here in the county, but not city ordinances, and certainly not the word of a mayor whose authority stops at the city limits. The officer's decision to force the camera's removal was the clearest acknowledgment anyone in authority offered that what was happening was wrong.

Exhibit · Faith Road
Loading video…

Chasity Royals, Kenny Royals, Jameson Herman, and an unknown female on my property installing a surveillance camera aimed at us. Jameson Herman makes an obscene gesture toward my wife, who was leaving our shop. The Royals and Hermans were walking up and down the road in a gang-like group. Mayor Hayes had declared this land a public right-of-way, and the city police — operating in the county — are backing him up, "just following orders." We are in the county, not the city. Mayor Hayes's authority here is nothing but tyranny.

Harassment and Escalation

Before all of this, I had already reported to police that the Royals and the Herman family, who lived nearby, were driving past my property at high speeds — apparently to kick up dust, this is a dirt road — and shouting obscenities as they passed. The neighbors denied any such behavior when officers asked them about it, and the officers suggested I install security cameras. I did.

In apparent retaliation for the cameras, the Royals and the Hermans trespassed on my property and installed a camera of their own — on my land and aimed at me. The same officer responded when I called. After contacting city officials, he was told that this constituted a public right-of-way and that anyone could use it — worth remembering, again, that this property isn't within the city at all. The officer disagreed with the camera placement, called it unreasonable, and forced the neighbors to remove it.

Exhibit · The Camera and the Officer A Geneva police officer standing beside the camera mounted on a steel post
The responding Geneva officer at the scene. He called the placement unreasonable and made them take the camera down. The posts here are the same Install 3 posts, several weeks on and faded by the sun.
Exhibit · The Camera Trail camera strapped to a steel post, aimed across the property
A trail camera strapped to one of the Install 3 posts on my property, aimed at us.
Even within a system aligned against me, that particular act was too far for the officer. I was thankful the city police officers are reasonable people. The property is not within the city limits but is within the city police jurisdiction, which means they can enforce state laws in that area — but not city ordinances or directives issued by the city. This road is maintained by the county and carries Hartford mailing addresses.

The Campground — and What Came After

I also owned the vacant property on the other side of Faith Road. For a time I had been in negotiations with Hussey House Movers about a home they were selling for relocation. They were asking a price I felt was too high. I made an offer, he declined my counter but said he had another buyer working on financing and would contact me if it fell through. It did fall through, and he came back to me with a price higher than what we had discussed. I declined, and frankly, after the battle with my neighbor on Faith Road, I had lost my enthusiasm for putting a nice home across the street from her.

My turn. I decided instead to put a trailer park on the property. My family talked me out of it and convinced me to build a campground. We ran the numbers and found that a campground would be considerably more profitable than a trailer park — and that removing a problem renter from a campground is a much simpler matter than evicting a tenant. They were right, my blood was still boiling but I listened to calmer heads. I had the land cleared and began moving forward.

When the Royals got wind of the plans, they did everything they could to stop it. They gathered signatures from some neighbors for a petition, which carried no weight. They contacted our County Commissioner, who told them plainly that I could put whatever I wanted on that property.

The Strangle Hold

The neighbors then installed metal fence posts, rope, and flags as close to the dirt road as they could manage. They placed a wooden post in the corner of the property near the curve. And Chasity Royals replanted her mailbox — installed in an oversized flower pot — then moved it incrementally closer into the road, apparently to prevent a camper from being able to exit the campground. Remember the road is just a prescriptive easement and not owned anyone on that road or any government entity.

The narrowing is in the curve and after the curve. The first stretch of Faith Road runs from Highway 52 straight into the Royals' driveway — they reach their own house without ever taking that curve. Restricting it costs them nothing. What is happening here is posts set on ground nobody has a claim to, moved further out each time the grader shifts over and the grass fills in, with nobody asking for them.

Exhibit · The Mailbox, Before Chasity Royals's mailbox set in the ground beside Faith Road, before it was replanted in a flower pot
Chasity Royals's mailbox where it stood in the ground, before she replanted it in an oversized flower pot and began moving it out into the road.Click the photograph to enlarge.
Exhibit · Faith Road · Driving Out
Loading video…

The view driving out from the campground property. The green flags on the left are Chasity Royals's. She and Kenny Royals narrowed the road with metal fence posts, rope, and flags set as close to the roadbed as they could manage, a wooden post at the curve, and a mailbox planted in an oversized flower pot that was moved incrementally further into the road — enough to keep a camper from being able to make the turn. Faith Road is a prescriptive easement. Neither the city, the county, nor anyone living on it holds title to it. Chasity put the fence up at the edge of the graded road. The road grader would move over a bit to avoid the fence, the grass would grow, then she would move the fence to the edge of the grass again. It is a slow process but it is effective. After I put the trailer on the property Chasity removed her fence. I guess she was thinking RVs would have been better than trailers.

The Well Problem

Because the Royals had abandoned their well in favor of city water, I needed them to sign a form for the Health Department officially confirming that abandonment. This was required so I could locate my septic drain field within 100 feet of where that well had been. Chasity Royals refused to sign and told the Health Department she intended to have the well repaired. That single refusal effectively strangled the project. Between the blocked road access and the septic restriction, the campground was no longer viable as planned. I wrote the Royals a letter explaining that if they did not sign, I would be forced to relocate the septic system and place a camper pad in that area instead, right in front of her house. This original plan would have left a clean grass strip 50 feet wide along the road between our properties, from the curve to the driveway exit on the far side. She never responded.

Exhibit · The Posts in the Curve Steel posts and wire set along the inside of the curve on Faith Road
Steel posts and wire set along the curve in front of Chasity Royals's yard. The telephone pole is approximately the property line. Cars stay to the inside of the curve, which is why grass grows on that ground at all — but a trailer or a camper has to swing wide across exactly that strip to make the turn. The posts made that impossible.Click the photograph to enlarge.

I was frustrated, and I threw in the towel on the campground. It was a real loss. While we were out there working, the Royals would play loud music and fire guns — clearly intended to discourage us. Chasity Royals even sat in her boat in her yard watching us work for hours. I could have pursued legal action over the road obstruction on grounds of prescriptive easement, but it simply was not worth the fight.

The Trailer

After stepping back from the campground, I decided to salvage something from the situation by returning to my original idea: a small trailer park. I had enough space and septic capacity for four to six small units, depending on size and bedroom count. I found a free trailer online — not ideal, but I had it moved onto the property, right into the location the septic restriction had forced me away from.

The trailer placed on the property, viewed from one end The trailer placed on the property, viewed from the other end
The trailer, set in the spot the septic restriction had forced me away from.Click to enlarge.

I will be honest: it was partly out of spite. A spite decision is an emotionally driven action intended to annoy another person, often at a high cost to oneself. The downfalls are real — strained relationships, and a lingering sense of unfulfilled vengeance. It is ultimately self-defeating. I was standing there when Chasity Royals arrived home. Chasity drove past very slowly, taking in the new view. I felt satisfied — for a moment.

I have two other lucrative projects that had taken priority, so the trailer has sat empty for several months. I have recently had a break in those projects and have begun working on it again.

✦

How Hayes and Austin Have Negatively Affected the Faith Road Community

There was a young couple with children living next to Chasity. The husband and I had maintained a neighborly relationship, but he eventually took up Chasity's dispute.

In the end, he realized that Chasity was wrong and that I was right. Shortly afterward, he moved away with his family. I assume this was out of embarrassment, or perhaps his wife insisted on it.

The tree-cutting crew I hired to clear my property later performed work for Chasity. By the second day, one of the crew members was standing in Chasity's yard yelling and trying to provoke a fight.

Additionally, three other men who live on the road no longer stop to talk as they occasionally had in the past. If I see these men in town, they will still speak with me — but not within view of Chasity's home. She has now aligned herself with the man renting the home the young couple moved out of, and he has turned un-neighborly as well.

Her husband, Kenny, has supported her position throughout this situation. However, when I spoke with him privately, without Chasity present, he seemed reasonable and receptive to my concerns.

Overall, the atmosphere on the road has deteriorated significantly.

I can't prove this, but I've wondered whether the county's next move was payback on the Mayor's behalf: not long after, the county filled in the roadside ditch, causing water to drain onto my property. When I asked why, I was told two vehicles couldn't pass on the road — but in 25 years of owning this property, vehicles always had.

✦

What This Was Really About

This was never just about a water meter. It was about a mayor who sat on both the city government and the Water Board, whose relationship with his utility manager placed an unqualified person in a position of authority, and whose willingness to call private land public — without the landowner present — set the entire machine in motion. It was about personal friendships between officials and neighbors being used as leverage against a citizen who simply said: this is my land, and you do not have the right.

The meter is off my property, but barely, and not where it should be. The record exists. And now, so does this account.

If Something Like This Is Happening to You Document everything, stand your ground, and do not assume the people with authority are the ones telling the truth. Photos and additional documentation will be added to this post. More to come.

A dotted underline marks information relayed to me by someone else that I could not independently confirm myself — I've said so plainly wherever it appears.

A Note on My Own Complaint

There is one paragraph in the complaint I filed that I want to point out myself.

Exhibit · Paragraph 25 Paragraph 25 of the complaint, referring to negligent construction of a home at 916 County Road 610, Enterprise, Alabama, with a handwritten note in the margin reading: not this case, another client's file
Paragraph 25 of my own complaint, as filed December 6, 2024. The red marks are mine, added here — the filed document has nothing written on it.Click the paragraph to enlarge.

The address and the home referenced are in Enterprise, in Coffee County, and have nothing to do with me or with Faith Road. It was an error on my attorney's part, and it never came up in the case. I have left it here rather than quietly fix it, because the whole point of this site is that the record is the record. The full complaint is here (PDF) if you want to read it yourself.

Disclaimer

This is an independent, privately operated website. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or associated with the City of Geneva, Geneva County government, the Geneva Water Works and Sewer Board, or any other governmental entity in any manner whatsoever. The accountability reporting on this page reflects the documented personal experience and opinion of a private property owner in Geneva County, Alabama. All factual claims are based on firsthand experience, documented records, on-the-record conversations, and — where noted in the text — information relayed to me by people I trust, which I could not independently confirm. Readers are encouraged to conduct their own research and draw their own conclusions. Nothing on this site constitutes legal advice.